News of 2nd March 2006
National | Shillong | International | Editorial | Regional | Sports

Protests greet Bush, US First Lady
Nuclear deal high on agenda
New Delhi: US President George Bush arrived here Wednesday evening on his maiden India voyage, keen to sew up a landmark nuclear agreement that he said was good for the world. Prime Minister Manmohan Singh broke protocol to personally receive Bush at the airport, an indication of the importance India attaches to the March 1-3 visit, the first by a US president in six years.
However, anti-Bush protests in New Delhi, Hyderabad, where Bush is scheduled to go Friday, and elsewhere around the country gave an indication of strong sentiments that his visit has provoked among those who oppose his aggressive global policies.
There was heavy security at Delhi airport with wired US Marines in black intermingling with Indian commandoes as the gleaming blue and white Air Force One touched down from Kabul. As the doors of the Boeing-747 opened, Bush, dressed in a back suit and a navy blue tie, stepped out accompanied by Laura. They waved to the dignitaries before briskly striding down the steps to be warmly greeted by Dr Singh.
Even as Bush greeted the dignitaries present at the airport, Dr Singh was engaged in an animated conversation with Secretary of State Condoleeza Rice, leading many to wonder whether they were clearing the final hurdles to the nuclear deal. Just before leaving Kabul, where he made an unscheduled halt becoming coming to New Delhi, Bush told a news conference along with Afghan President Ahmed Karzai that both sides were working on the civil nuclear agreement but said it was going to be a "difficult" one to negotiate for both countries.
Without undertaking whether the agreement would be signed during his visit, Bush said "it is in the interest of countries around the world that India has a nuclear power industry."
Indian authorities threw a security blanket never seen in New Delhi for any head of state, with anti-Bush protestors pledging to take to the streets in thousands against his visit. In a foretaste of things to come, tens of thousands of Muslims and others staged a noisy protest in the capital against Bush, with the chief organiser calling the US president a "terrorist" for his policies in Iraq and Afghanistan. Effigies of Bush went up in flames at the Ramlila ground in the heart of the city, a venue that will see another major anti-Bush rally organised by the communists Thursday.
Condoleezza Rice set the tone for the visit while speaking to reporters on board Air Force One flying Bush to New Delhi. "We would very much like to have a (civilian nuclear) deal; we are going to continue to work at it. But if we don't have one for this trip, then we will continue to work at it," Rice maintained.
Rice also enunciated a sticking point between the two countries on India's plan to separate its civilian and nuclear military facilities by asking New Delhi to place power reactors under "permanent safeguards," and clarified that Washington understands that not "every reactor" will be placed under safeguards. (Agencies)
Mutton dishes for Bush as chicken off the fare
New Delhi: While the bird flu scare has knocked off any chicken dishes from the menu on offer for US President George W. Bush at the official banquet Thursday, he will be able to tuck into a delectable variety of fare including mutton biryani and korma. The visiting dignitaries from the US will also be able to savour other dishes like fried prawns, fried fish, continental delicacies and broccoli soup.
The special four-course dinner being hosted by President A.P.J. Abdul Kalam for Bush and his wife Laura will be held in Rashtrapati Bhavan's expansive Mughal Gardens instead of the customary Banquet Hall.
"We found the weather is pleasant in the evenings and decided to shift the venue. There will be over 15 tables laid out for the guests," said a Presidential aide.Bush will be served a 'special dish' of his liking that will be prepared by the chefs in Rashtrapati Bhavan in consultation with the US embassy. A guest list of nearly 100 VIPs has been drawn up for the dinner. . (IANS)
Poll dates
New Delhi:
A staggered multi-phased polling beginning April 3 and ending May 8 has been announced for the Assembly elections in five states including West Bengal, where an unprecendented five-day polling has been fixed against the backdrop of complaints against the ruling Left Front there. (PTI)UP drama
Lucknow:
In a new twist to the fast-paced political drama in Uttar Pradesh, Assembly Speaker Mata Prasad Pandey Wednesday night virtually recognised rebel BSP MLAs supporting the Mulayam Singh Yadav government with hints of action under anti-defection law against deserters from this group after three ministers resigned.A day after the Allahabad High Court stuck down the decision of an earlier Speaker approving the split in BSP and the subsequent merger of 40 MLAs with ruling Samajwadi Party, Pandey said the rebel group would henceforth function as an independent outfit Jantantrik Bahujan Dal. (PTI)
Incidents of violence on the rise in N-E: Centre
New Delhi:
Goverment today said incidents of violence in North-Eastern states have increased and it has been decided to set up a joint intelligence coordination mechanism for information gathering."During the year 2005, while the number of violent incidents has marginally increased by eight per cent, the number of security forces' personnel and civilians killed, has decreased by 37 per cent and six per cent respectively as compared to 2004," Minister of State for Home S Regupahty told Rajya Sabha in a reply. He said the government had last year decided Directors General of Police of North Eastern states will meet at periodic intervals for joint intelligence coordination.
"It was decided to include states of Arunachal Pradesh, Mizoram and Mainpur also in this arrangement," he said. (PTI)
Five states go to polls in April-May
New Delhi: The Election Commission on Wednesday announced a staggered multi-phased polling assembly elections in West Bengal, Kerala and Assam and Pondicherry and a single-day for Tamil Nadu beginning on April 3 and ending May eight. Counting of votes in all the states will be taken up on May 11, Chief Election Commissioner B B Tandon told a press conference here announcing the timetable. The model of code of conduct comes into force immediately.
In the Left Front-ruled West Bengal, where the Commission had been active in the last few months removing huge chunks of bogus voters from electoral rolls, an unprecedented five-phase polling on April 17, 22, 27, May 3 and 8 has been fixed.
Similarly, Kerala will also witness an extended polling schedule spread over three days April 22, 29 and May five, something unusual for the state known for clean and violence-free polls. Tamil Nadu will go to polls on a single day on May eight. In the neighbouring union territory of Pondicherry, election will be held on May eight in 27 constituencies while in Mahe (adjoining Kerala), Yamam (adjoining Andhra Pradesh) and Palloor the election will be on May three.
Election in Assam will be held in two phases on April three and April ten. Assam has a 126-member assembly, Kerala 140, Tamil Nadu 234, West Bengal 294 and Pondicherry 30. Tandon said the decision on five-phased elections in West Bengal was made taking into consideration "various ground realities" like area domination, availability of central paramilitary forces in naxal-affected areas.
"I think so", he said when asked this was the first time that the polling in West Bengal would be spread over five phases. "We want to have a good and peaceful poll in all the states," he added.
To a question what prompted EC to have a single-day vote in Tamil Nadu vis-a-vis five phases in West Bengal, Tandon said all political parties in Tamil Nadu wanted a single-day poll and the decision was also based on the Commission's own assessment.
Polling in all the four states and union territory of Pondicherry would be held through Electronic Voting Machines (EVMs), Tandon said. Observing that the progress in issuance of Electors Photo Identity Cards (EPIC) was "not very happy" in Tamil Nadu with a mere 55 per cent coverage, he said it was almost cent per cent in Kerala and Pondicherry and 92.13 per cent in West Bengal. The programme in Assam could not be started due to various reasons, he added.
For the first time, the EC has decided to change the marking of indelible ink which would now run from top of the nail to the bottom of the first joint of the left fore-finger of a voter. Observing that all officials engaged in the conduct of polls should discharge their duties in an impartial manner and without fear, he warned of strict action against those found wanting on any account.
The EC has instructed the state authorities not to allow any civil or police official above the rank of sub inspector to be in his home district during the poll period. Instructions have also been issued that such officials would not be allowed to continue in the same district if they have completed three years of posting there during the last four years. Tandon said the Election Commission has directed the poll-bound states to ensure that those who stand transferred should move out physically of their last place of posting and not remain there on any pretext including leave. (PTI)
Sushmita’s car impounded
Mumbai:
Officials of the Directorate of Revenue Intelligence (DRI) seized Bollywood actress Sushmita Sen's imported Toyota Land Cruiser, which she had bought in May 2005. DRI officials said that the car would be returned to the actress after she coughed up Rs.20 lakhs as customs duty. The car has been valued at Rs.56 lakhs.DRI sources further informed that the luxury car imported with accompanying documents allegedly stated the date of manufacture as December 1998 while the actual date of manufacture was 2003.The sources said that both the importer and the broker had fudged the chassis number of the vehicle, which was brought under the transfer of residence (TR) scheme that mandates that the vehicle has to be used by the importer for two years before being further sold off.
DRI sources notified that they had sought the original manufacturing information from the manufacturer Toyota to ascertain the actual date of manufacture and conducted scrutiny of the vehicle to confirm that it was manufactured in 2003. Sen, who purchased the car from dealer Haren Choksi, was not available for comment. (ANI)
SC to curtail summer vacation
New Delhi:
The Supreme Court has decided to crurtail the summer holidays by a week and will set up Special Benches during the vacation to hear pending cases.Modifying the list of apex court holidays and summer vacation for the year 2006, an official notification said instead of eight weeks, the summer vaction will be for seven weeks from May 15 to July 2.Earlier notification had fixed the summer vacation from May 15 to July 9.Registrar General V K Jain informed the media that during the vacation Special Benches will sit for old pending cases.He said the decision has been taken in this regard and it will be worked out on the number of such Special Benches. (PTI)
Par okays Minority (Amendment) Bill
New Delhi: Parliament on Wednesday approved a bill to provide right to minority educational institutions to seek affiliation to any university of their choice with the government assuring the members that it would not in any way interfere with the functioning of any educational institution.
The National Commission for Minority Educational Institutions (Amendment) Bill, 2005, already passed by the Lok Sabha, was okayed by the Rajya Sabha after opposition from the BJP which charged the Congress-Led UPA government with playing vote bank politics.
Replying to a debate on the bill in Rajya Sabha, Minister of State for Human Resource Development M A A Fatmi said minority educational institutions were facing difficulties in getting no objection certificates for setting up educational institutions and the legislation was brought to remove these hurdles.
He assured the House that applicants seeking affiliations could directly approach the Commission if they had failed to get no objection certificates from states. Fatmi dismissed apprehensions raised by some members that the legislation would interfere in the functioning of institutions like UGC saying norms applicable to other institutions would be applicable to minority educational institutions.
With regard to extending reservations in minority educational institutions to community members living below poverty line, the Minister said this was a separate issue and could be discussed later.
No emigration clearance to women seeking jobs as housemaids
Government has banned grant of emigration clearance to women below the age of 30 years seeking employment as housemaids or domestic workers in any foreign country.
In a written reply in Lok Sabha, Overseas Indian Affairs Minister Vayalar Ravi admitted that it had come to the notice of government that several Indian women going abroad for jobs face exploitation. He, however, said "though there have been general reports regarding exploitation of Indian women going abroad for employment, there has been no specific complaint." He ruled out the possibility of any separate legislation in this regard.
Travel advice to Australian, Canadian citizens
The Government on Wednesday admitted in the Lok Sabha that Canada and Australia have cautioned their citizens against travelling to North Eastern states and border areas, including Jammu and Kashmir citing adverse law and order situation. (PTI)
Two Delhi hospitals on standby for Bush
New Delhi: Sir Ganga Ram Hospital and Indraprastha Apollo Hospitals, two super-specialty health centres here, will be the standby medical facilities during US President George W. Bush’s three-day visit to India from Wednesday.
"US officials inspected our facilities, found our services were to their satisfaction and issued a letter designating us as the standby hospital for the US president and other dignitaries," said S.K. Sama, chairman of Sir Ganga Ram Hospital.
"We have reserved two rooms for this purpose," Sama, who also officiates as the hospital’s medical director, told IANS.
Apollo officials said after a similar inspection, the US Embassy and the Secret Service had told them to standby for any emergency. "Our ambulance will follow Bush’s cavalcade in Delhi. A team of doctors from our hospital and US health services will be inside it to meet any health requirements," said an Apollo spokesman.
"Two rooms have been checked, reserved and sealed. We hope the president’s visit will be completed without any problem, but in case of any emergency we are ready to tackle it."
Officials at Sir Ganga Ram Hospital said it was the official medical facility for the US embassy. "Whenever dignitaries come from the US, we make special arrangements for them," a hospital spokesman said.(IANS)
‘Official’ dogs get presidential treatment
A five-star hotel in the Indian capital is playing host to a special team that is part of US President George Bush’s security entourage - some 65 dogs that are referred to as "officials".
The specially trained dogs were flown in as part of the multi-layer security for Bush and have been put up in deluxe rooms at the Le Meridien Hotel in central Delhi.
Students happy with 15 min cool-off time
New Delhi: The CBSE’s Annual Board Examinations began on a relaxed note on Wednesday, with Class XII students taking the English paper and giving a good feedback on the 15-minutes "cool-off" time introduced this year.More than four lakh students appeared for their Class XII exams in over 2400 centres across the country and abroad.
The exam jitters, however, seem to have been eased by the 15 minutes extra time that will be given to the students before each paper as a "cool-off" period.
"It is a good idea. The extra time helped me calm myself before I began answering the questions," said Ragini Tarneja, a Class XII student from a public school in the capital.However, Anubhav Sahni, another Class XII student from Delhi, said the 15 minutes would prove to be more useful while taking tougher papers like physics, chemistry and mathematics. A total of 4,54,045 students -- 2,63,286 boys and 1,90,759 girls -- including 6,495 foreign students, appeared for their English paper, kickstarting the month-long examination season with certain new features.
The examinations for Class X will begin tomorrow.Providing a big relief to students, the CBSE has this time restructured certain important question papers and given the examinees an extra time of 15 minutes before each paper.
The Board has restructured Mathematics, Social Science and Science papers of Class 10 and Physics, Business Studies, Chemistry, Biology, Mathematics, Economics and Accountancy question papers for Class XII.Without changing the number of questions, the Board has rearranged their pattern like reducing the word requirement of long-answer questions so that students can finish their paper in time. Also, the students will get an additional time of 30 minutes for revising their answer sheets for certain important papers. (PTI)
Salem implicates Sanjay Dutt in blasts case
Mumbai: Extradited don Abu Salem has confessed that he delivered arms and ammunition to Bollywood star Sanjay Dutt at the latter's residence before the 1993 Mumbai serial blasts that killed nearly 300 people.
Abu Salem's confession to the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) was made public Wednesday after the designated TADA court here opened a sealed envelope containing his statements.Abu Salem, accused of masterminding the Mumbai blasts that until then was the worst urban terror attack, told the investigative agency that he had delivered three AK-56 rifles and some cartages to Dutt. Dutt who was present in the TADA - Terrorist And Disruptive Activities (Prevention) Act - court is one of 123 people accused in the blasts case that shook the country's financial capital.
According to the confessional document, Abu Salem carried the weapons in a white car, provided by his accomplice Riyaz Siddiqui, to Dutt's residence. Salem's lawyer Ashok Sarogi, however, said that his client had no idea that he was transporting weapons to Dutt. Salem was apparently told that he was carrying a consignment of silver.
"All the confessional statements from Abu Salem has been taken by force," Sarogi told mediapersons outside the TADA court. The copies of the confession will be furnished to defence cou-nsel. Salem's confession will have an impact on Dutt only if the case is reopened and the don is included in the trial.
Experts say this is unlikely, considering the scale of the case and the time it has already taken, which is over 10 years. The TADA court on Wednesday opened the sealed envelope containing Salem's confession to the CBI regarding his role in the blasts.
Abu Salem, a former aide of underworld don Dawood Ibrahim who allegedly now lives in Pakistan, was extradited to India Nov 11 from Portugal along with his companion and former Bollywood actress Monica Bedi. (Agencies)

Tiwari for thrust on rural employment
By Our Reporter
SHILLONG:
Raising the standard of living of the ruralites and adoption of meaningful economic activities in remote areas are going to be the thrust areas for State's Chief Secretary Mr SK Tiwari. Marketing State's horticultural products, diversification of bamboo based products, increase in industrial, tourism and IT activities are some of the priority areas for Mr Tiwari, who assumed office on Tuesday.Mr Tiwari took the hot seat with a clear vision to develop rural Meghalaya during the next one-year of his tenure.According to him, employment avenues in rural areas should be increased by encouraging people to take up horticulture. Countering the notion about self-employment and business activities through self-help, Mr Tiwari said: "The basic idea is to create jobs as only jobs can provide security to the people. Not everybody can be businessmen, hence we will have to create jobs", he said.
"We have large scale production of ginger and turmeric in Meghalaya. The government needs to make efforts to market these produces for economic benefit of the growers. We also need to ensure that growers of horticultural produces get fair price", Mr Tiwari told reporters on Wednesday.
"Oranges and pineapples, besides other fruits could be processed for value addition for domestic consumption - that is for sale within the State", he said.
The Chief Secretary said there should be more concentration on growing of bamboo and diversification of bamboo products. "The bamboo cultivation could provide jobs for it having a huge scope for value addition", he said. He said the migration of people from rural areas to urban centres could be checked, if jobs were provided in rural sectors. He stressed the need for setting up of more industries in the State for job opportunity.
Seven houses gutted
By Our Reporter
SHILLONG:
Seven houses were gutted on Tuesday evening at Nongkohlew village under Mawlai constituency causing extensive damage to the household.According to sources, the fire started from one house, but due to strong wind spread rapidly and destroyed six other adjacent houses in succession.Mawlai MLA PT Sawkmie visited the affected families on the following day and extended some immediate relief to them.
Police clueless in banker's murder case
By Our Reporter
SHILLONG: Even three days after the killing of the State Bank of India, Zonal Office Assistant Manager Winner Kharshandi, police failed to make any breakthrough.Kharshandi was shot dead by some unidentified armed miscreants on Monday while he was on the way to Shillong after visiting his relatives at Thiedieng village near Mawsynran in East Khasi Hills.
According to police, the investigation to identify the killers was still on and said to be clueless as of now. However, there are indications that the murder could have been due to some personal grudge. Sources said efforts were on to track down the killers who are still at large.
2 more held for Customs official’s murder
By Our Reporter
SHILLONG:
Police have arrested two more persons in connection with the murder of J Das, Superintendent of Bholaganj Land Customs Station.Identified as Duleep Mushahari and Ananta Munda, a limestone supplier, the duo hired Jotil Boro, the main accused in the murder. Earlier, Boro was arrested by the police on February 24.Police said Boro abducted Das and later handed over to two Bangladeshis who were waiting in the border to carry out the murder. They strangulated the Custom official.Boro was paid Rs 20,000 for this, police said adding that the former also confessed that these two persons were involved in the crime.
One Killed: One person died on the spot when the motorbike he was riding collided with a truck at Lad Smit at around 9.30 pm on Wednesday.
State equipped to tackle bird flu
By Our Reporter
SHILLONG:
In am attempt to ally fears from the minds of people about avian flu, the State Animal Husbandry and Veterinary department gave a clean chit to chicken and eggs consumption, "if they are properly cooked". In a statement issued here on Wednesday, the department requested the public to contact the nearest veterinary doctors if they notice any signs and symptoms of birds suffering, which usually happens during windy season.The department said, "As of today, there have been no confirmed case of bird flu in the State, or for that matter any report of outbreak of avian flu in any part of Northeast".
In spite of this, the department is continuously monitoring the situation on a day-to-day basis, the department statement said. All district AH&V officers have been instructed to keep a strict vigil in their respective check posts and rapid response team would be dealing with any emergency situation arising from any incidence of poultry It said that necessary precautionary measures were taken against bird flu as required under the action plan by the Central government.
State to seek plan outlay of Rs 896 cr
By Our Reporter
SHILLONG: The annual plan outlay of Meghalaya for 2006-2007 will be finalised by the Planning Commission in Delhi on March 7, official sources on Wednesday said. Chief Minister DD Lapang and Chief Secretary SK Tiwari will leave for Delhi on March 6 for a meeting with the Planning Commission officials.
Earlier, the State government had worked out the plan size of Rs 896 crore - an increase of 12 per cent over the last year's plan outlay of Rs 800 crore. The State government is likely to ask more funds from the Planning Commission for the enhanced annual plan size this time.
Usually, the Planning Commission allows only 10 per cent increase in the plan outlay from the previous year. However, breaking the norms, Meghalaya is asking for a 12 per cent hike.
The Centre had directed the State government to stress on rural development, food security with special emphasis on agriculture, organic farming, production of meat, eggs, fish and improvement in social service sector including education and health care. Other priority areas are road connectivity, fisheries, sericulture, youth and sports affairs.
Uranium mining in national interest: CEM
By Our Reporter
SHILLONG: The Chief Executive Member of KHADC, Mr HS Shylla has made an impassioned plea for allowing uranium mining at Mawthabah under West Khasi Hills in greater interest of the country. "Since we have such a precious mineral like uranium, we should mine it instead of being led by unjustified fears. We should consider the interest of our country and be proud of our contribution to the country's nuclear strength", Mr Shylla said.
Responding to points raised by the members of the Council during a general discussion on the vote-on-account, Mr Shylla said the proposed road from Wahkaji to Mawthabah was needed for the benefit of local villagers and informed the House that Centre already sanctioned Rs 19 crore for the project.
The proposed road has already been sanctioned to the Uranium Corporation of India Limited (UCIL), which entered into an agreement with the KHADC for execution of the project. Mr Shylla said irrespective of whether uranium mining was allowed or not, the UCIL agreed to sanction the construction of the proposed road.
Reacting to some allegations brought against the Lafarge Cement for "suppressing tribal interest on its land at Nongtrai near Shella for limestone mining", the CEM said, "Since the matter is subjudiced, the KHADC was only asking the company to pay its royalty directly to the Council instead of routing through the State government".
The Leader of Opposition, Mr Bindo M Lanong and another Member Mr HL Massar brought this allegation, while making the present CEM responsible for the same.
The House also passed the vote-on-account amounting to more than Rs 12.33 crore for the period from April 1 to June 30 in which the maximum portion was sought for payment of salary to the KHADC staff, including clearance of arrears, dearness allowance and dearness pension.
Earlier, during the question hour, Executive Member (Trade) Ronnie V Lyngdoh said that the Council issued 569 trading licences to non-tribal traders during the period from March 2004-2005. The CEM informed the House about 51 number of cases pending in various Courts, including one in Supreme Court, besides 45 in High Court. Five are lying in various lower courts, the CEM said.
Sawkmie moots retention of Wahlang
By Our Reporter
SHILLONG:
The State Resource Mobilization Commission Co-Chairman, Mr PT Sawkmie, on Wednesday urged Chief Minister DD Lapang to retain the East Khasi Hills Deputy Commissioner Mr DP Wahlang for all his efforts in maintaining law and order in the entire district.In a letter to the Chief Minister on Wednesday, Mr Sawkmie highlighted Mr Wahlang as an able officer who showed his capability to control law and order situation in Shillong, at a time when the MBOSE issue snowballed into a major public unrest in Garo Hills last year. There was all around development all over the district, besides transparency and accountability finding a focus.
Besides giving a formal letter to the Chief Minister, Mr Sawkmie also met Mr Lapang and discussed the issue with him. Mr Sawkmie claimed that the Chief Minister assured him that he would take up the matter with his cabinet colleagues for "examination".
The notification for transfer of Mr Wahlang was issued on Tuesday and he would be replaced by another senior IAS officer Pankaj Jain.
BSNL cable stolen
By Our Reporter
SHILLONG: Unidentified miscreants stole about 800 metres overhead telephone cable of the BSNL worth Rs 50,000 from Wahingdoh and Mawlai Phudmawri areas on Tuesday. Informing this here on Wednesday, a top BSNL official said a similar incident took place in the month of December at Umsohsun and Garikhana Stand Jeep.
A book to trace judicial roots in Khasi Hills to hit stands soon
By Our Reporter
SHILLONG: Governor Mr MM Jacob on Tuesday released the book titled 'Administration of Justice in the Khasi Hills' authored by Dr (Ms) Ebanoris Jyrwa at a function held in Raj Bhavan. Addressing the gathering on the occasion, Mr Jacob said that the book is an innocent attempt to trace the legal and judicial system prevalent in Khasi Hills.
Mr Jacob said, "Even during the British rule the legal administrative system developed in this part of the country is very different from what is followed in the rest of the country". He said that in matters related to the administration of justice the local traditional system followed by the tribal people was preserved and the tribals were allowed to administer justice according to their customs.
Meanwhile, he said, "Under the British Raj, the Khasi and Jaintia Hills was divided into two parts - 'Khasi and Jaintia Hills District' and 'Khasi States'. "The 'Khasi States' one of the Indian States that acceded to the Dominion of India are not parts of British India, in so far as the administration of justice is concerned, the administration for the Khasi and Jaintia Hills District was governed by the Rules of the administration of justice in Khasi Hills and policies prescribed by the Governor", Mr Jacob said.
Mr Jacob said that with the introduction of District Council by the Sixth Scheduled of the Constitution of India, after independence, the judicial administration in the district is bifurcated between the Deputy Commissioner and the District Council, adding that it has also curtailed the powers and functions of local chiefs and traditional organizations to a very large extent.
Significantly the Megha-laya Governor also stressed on the need to consider the separation of the judiciary from the executive thus giving his thoughts to the burning topic of the day. He felt that the time has come for "considering the separation of the executive from the judiciary, keeping in view the recent Supreme court decision on the same."
Mr Jacob said, "The traditional system of administration of justice has helped to preserve the identity of the tribes and promote dispensation of quick and inexpensive justice, on the negative side, one can say that the system has become too static for too long and has failed to keep peace with the changing times".
Further he said that this book is a valuable asset and contributes significantly to exsisting knowledge on the unique system of administration of Justice in the Khasi Hills exsisting with the modern legal system.

Political calculations
After the compact disc episode cherubic Amar Singh, SP general secretary, is now trying hard to wriggle out of the mess he finds himself. He insists that he has the right to discuss the attitudes of judges in office; all politicians might be doing so. But has such a thing come into the open in the past? Not perhaps in recent times. To the further embarrassment of Mr Mulayam Singh Yadav and Mr. Amar Singh, the RSS came up with the suggestion that as in Karnataka, the BJP could consider setting up an alliance with Mr. Yadav in U.P. It is well known that the BJP, now led by Mr. Rajnath Singh, has a secret understanding with Mr. Mulayam Singh, who survives in office with defectors from Mayawati's Bahujan Samaj Party. Why not formalize the arrangement that the two Thakur leaders, Mr. Amar Singh and Mr. Rajnath Singh, might have made. In Karnataka the BJP is now the junior partner of a government led by the son of Mr. H.D.Deve Gowda who leads a breakaway faction of a secular party. Yet there is much discontent in the Karnataka BJP as a number of aspiring MLAs have failed to secure Ministerial offices. That could be a flashpoint between secular and rightist parties. Yet, secularism is basically anathema to BJP as it amounts to minorityism in the lexicon of Mr. L.K.Advani. But for political expediency, support of secularism is all right if the BJP could get its foot in the door in the most populous State of India, that is Uttar Pradesh. The BJP hopes that if it can try to be part of government in one more State, it could perhaps dream of returning to power at the Centre after three years when a new Lok Sabha has to be elected.
In Bihar, there is already a precedent in the BJP alliance with Mr Nitish Kumar's JD (U). In spite of all the controversy over the former Governor, Mr. Buta Singh's antics in dissolving the previous Bihar Assembly on the charge of horse-trading of MLAs and barring a JD (U)-BJP alliance taking office early last year, the BJP and Mr. Nitish Kumar are pleased that the end result of a fresh election after Assembly dissolution has given them an overwhelming majority whereas in February last year, they would have had a paper thin majority and their government would have been skating on thin ice. The BJP and the RSS are assessing the developing political situation in the country and devising strategies, some new ones, some harking back to old times, to prepare for elections to five legislative Assemblies this year.
![]()
![]()
Muslim headcount in Army
Hypocrisy or misconceived fears?
By Praful Bidwai
`It is extremely unfortunate that the government has dropped the move to collate data on the status of Muslims in the armed forces. This follows an uproar over the steps taken by the "Prime Minister’s High-Level Committee" (PMHC) on "the social economic and educational status of the Muslim community" headed by former justice Rajinder Sachar to approach the defence forces for such data. The protest was raucous or political. The Bharatiya Janata Party sought the President’s intervention in his capacity as the Supreme Commander of the armed forces to stop this "misguided" survey. Former army officers held dharnas against the "divisive" move, which they believe, would "weaken" a robustly secular institution. And former Defence Minister George Fernandes termed the PMHC’s work a "seditious act" aimed at "communalising" the armed forces!
After this, much of the media simply renamed the PMHC the "Sachar Committee". The Congress defensively pleaded that its survey would be "purely a data-gathering and fact-finding exercise." The PMO quickly distanced itself from the Committee. Chief of Army Staff Gen J.J. Singh said : "It is not the army’s philosophy to disseminate or maintain [community-wise] information"; we are not concerned with "the faith or language" of the people employed or "where they come from." And the Defence Ministry, which had sought the relevant data from the armed services, assured them it won’t forward it to the PMHC.
In the heat of emotion, it was all but forgotten that in our Parliamentary system, the President is not the court of last resort. He is the defence services’ Supreme Commander in a figurative sense. He does not possess the executive authority to start or stop a survey. Since then, former Deputy Chief of Army Staff Lt Gen R.S. Kadyan has approached the Supreme Court to ask that the survey be stayed. He argues the survey would help to "sow the seed of communalism in the defence forces."
Numerous arguments were advanced by opponents of the move. These hold that the very conduct of the survey would tarnish the armed forces’ image as a professional force; that words like "caste", "creed", "religion" and "reservation" are unheard-of in regimental messes; that the army is one of the few reliably secular institutions in India, which is fully trusted by the religious minorities -- unlike the police or paramilitary forces; it has an enviable record of protecting the lives of the minorities in communally charged situations.
Some of these arguments are undoubtedly valid. For instance, no one can seriously question the army’s secular credentials and its impartial role in protecting the life and property of the minorities when called upon to do so. The Indian army represents a remarkable achievement. It’s one of the few apolitical militaries in the Third World to function fully under civilian control. And yet, the ant-survey arguments miss one essential paradox: namely, that the army does not fully reflect the rich diversity and plurality of Indian society. It suffers from under-representation of certain ethnic, religious and social groups, and from over-representation of some others, most notably the so-called "martial races" favoured under the colonial system of recruitment, including Sikhs, Gorkhas, Dogras, Jats, Rajputs, etc.
Among the under-represented groups are people from the Northeast, Dalits, OBCs, and Muslims. We know from a note sent on January 9 by the army to the Defence Ministry that in 2004 it had only 29,093 Muslims among a total of 11 lakh personnel -- a ratio of 2.6 per cent, which compares poorly with the Muslims’ 13 per cent share in the Indian population. Similarly, there have been complaints of under-representation from Dalit and Adivasi leaders and smaller linguistic groups. To demand that their recruitment be increased is not to advance an anti-national, communal or divisive agenda, but to ask for diversity and balance. None other than former Defence Minister Jagjivan Ram raised the demand for greater Dalit recruitment in 1971.
Indeed, Jawaharlal Nehru, India’s greatest Prime Minister, who cannot even be remotely accused of a communal bias, noted in 1953 that "in our Defence Services, there are hardly any Muslims left… What concerns me most is that there is no effort being made to improve this situation, which is likely to grow worse unless checked." This concern was reiterated by Mahavir Tyagi, then Minister of State for Defence, who disclosed that "the percentage of Muslims in the armed forces, which was 32 per cent at the time of Partition has come down to two… I have instructed that due regard should be paid to their recruitment."
The PMHC was not being wayward in asking for information about the recruitment and status of Muslims in the army. It’s vital to collect "authentic information about the social, economic and educational status" of Muslims in different government departments. Without such a data bank, we won’t know whether there is under-representation of different groups, what its extent is, and what its causes might be. Collating such information is also the best way of countering prejudices about "minority appeasement".
True, such information is relevant not just for Muslims; it is necessary for other groups too. But the PMHC’s brief pertains to Muslims. It was perfectly legitimate for it to solicit information about Muslims. This is in keeping with the National Common Minimum Programme of the UPA, which promised to promote the welfare of socially and economically backward sections among religious and linguistic minorities.
The issue of Muslim under-representation in the defence forces must be situated in context. As MIT-based scholar Omar Khalidi argues in his Khaki and the Ethnic Violence in India (Three Essays, New Delhi, 2003), the army embraced the discredited colonial "martial races" theory which favoured certain "Fixed Classes" like Gorkhas, Sikhs, Dogras and Rajputs in recruitment. Muslims were excluded from these, except for groups such as the Qaimkhani community of Rajasthan and UP, and units like the Grenadiers, Armoured Corps, Bombay Engineers Group and the J&K Light Infantry. It’s only in 1984, after the "revolt" by some soldiers of the Sikh Regiment following "Operation Bluestar," that the army adopted a better mix in what’s called the "All-India Class".
Yet, the proportion of Muslims in the army remains under 3 per cent. In the case of officers, this may be explained by educational backwardness among Muslims. But this cannot explain the community’s low representation among Other Ranks. We need to know whether this is because of a reluctance of Muslims to join the army, skewed distribution of recruitment, or because of unacknowledged barriers to entry, including prejudices.
Gen Kadyan’s petition is wrong to allege that if such information is collated, "it will create very illogical and unnecessary data which might create… in the mind of the minority communities… a feeling of their being less in number in the defence forces… giving them cause for… fear of the majority community." This presumption is fundamentally mistaken. There’s nothing "illogical" about documenting the status of different communities in national institutions. The United States army, for instance, regularly compiles publicly available data on Muslims, Blacks, and other ethnic groups.
More generally, the armed forces cannot be an exception to the concept of citizenship in a multi-ethnic society. Nor can they demand to be shielded from scrutiny just because they perform a role in India’s defence. All citizens have a valid role to play in our national life. Real security derives not just from military defence, but other things including human security, justice, social cohesion and human rights. The armed forces are not a Holy Cow. A data bank on the ethnic-religious composition of all our public institutions is a precondition for measures to promote the welfare of citizens, including affirmative action in favour of the underprivileged and under-recruited. It goes without saying that this should not take the form of quotas and job reservations. But that’s not an argument against diversifying recruitment or promoting equality of opportunity. There’s no reason why the government cannot unilaterally announce that it will endeavour to recruit more and more under-represented groups without embracing a quota system. A caring-and-sharing society must have adequate room for such measures.
Two other points are in order. In many countries, promotion of inclusive multi-cultural policies and diversity became possible only when they abandoned ostrich-like attitudes and confronted reality. For instance, the British police began an internal evaluation after the race riots of the early 1980s. An extensive survey was undertaken of the ethnic composition of the force and prevalence of race- and ethnicity-related biases. This prepared the ground for diversity sensitisation programmes, retraining, and positive discrimination.
Second, there is disturbing evidence that certain Indian security- and intelligence-related agencies simply don’t recruit Muslims. These include the Research & Analysis Wing, Intelligence Bureau and National Security Guard. This is totally unacceptable and unworthy of a plural society that aspires to a degree of equity. Even the CIA would be embarrassed if it were to exclude African-Americans. The PMHC should thoroughly probe such institutions. Exclusion, and attitudes that rationalise it in the name of "security", are the surest recipe for alienation of our own citizens. We cannot afford this if we want a minimally decent and self-confident India. (IPA Service)
An ailing outdoor training.
Sir,
Through your esteemed daily I would like to draw the attention of the concerned high authorities towards the factors, which has been ailing the outdoor training in NEPA in recent times. Aged officers like Mr Jitendra Singh has been engaged on deputation to impart the training in the academy. This is undoubtedly having an adverse impact on the trainees. In a training institute like NEPA, young and energetic officers should be deputed to make the training schedules fruitful.
Another ailing factor is that, some of the outdoor instructors are very fond of using mobile phones of some trainees, which creates an adverse reaction on the others. Moreover, showing favour, using slang languages and lack of discipline among the instructors and others has become a regular practice that is ailing the outdoor atmosphere in NEPA.
Through this, I would like to request the concerned authorities to look into the matter urgently in the interest of the trainees in particular and that of the academy in general.
Yours etc.,
Bikash Pradhan
Lower Mawprem, Shillong.
Disenchantment with Govt. services
Sir,
According to a recently published news item, a large number of young and brilliant Civil Service Officers, have found themselves disillusioned with the nature of services they are rendering to the Govt. establishments both at the Central and State levels as they have discovered them to be less challenging, want of transparency and thus their spirit of dynamism wedded to societal developments are stunted for one reason or other.
They are in essence, at the cross road of their vocational career; this is in view of the fact that their bold decision and righteous actions are invariably reigned in by the Ministers/politicians and the mafia group remotely controlling our administrative functionality. Consequent upon this outcome, many promising bureaucrats have resigned from their lucrative posts and landed themselves in non-govt. enterprises like the Sahara, Reliance group of Industries and such other flourishing corporate houses. The management of these personnel who form the cream of the intellectual section of the society will prove indispensable.
These ex-bureaucrats will have a free level playing field whereupon they can promote the revenue earnings of the private concerns, their services for that matter could not have come at a better time.
View against the above background, one cannot but fall in line with these disgruntled bureaucrats given the face that even in our state of Meghalaya the same syndrome is prevalent. Some of my friends employed in government establishments responsible for overseeing the implementation of varied rural oriented welfare schemes have found themselves in an unenviable position a their bonafide monitoring reports have ended up gathering dust in some corners of govt. shelves which is indicative of the fall out of rampant corruptions where the dishonest functionaries are being shielded by some vested interests yielding potential power.
Yours etc.,
P U Diengdoh
Shillong 14.

Kyndiah hails Budget proposals
From Our Spl Correspondent
New Delhi: The Union Budget which received mixed response from different quarters, was Wednesday hailed by the the Minister of the Tribal Affairs and Development of North Eastern Region (DoNER), P.R. Kyndiah as a path breaking budget for the long neglected region.
Not only there is a hike in allocation to the DONER ministry but also the region gained from increase in allocation to other ministries. But the main benefit came from sevral central government mega schemes in the ministries of Rural Development and Surface Transport and Highways," Kyndiah said.
The Minister said that the Tribal Affairs Ministry has been given its due importance and the North Eastern Region has no doubt, got a fair deal. The Ministry of Development of North Eastern Region , (DoNER) including North Eastern Council is getting due share of importance and focus, he said.
"The bulk of the resources– Sarva Siksha Abhiyan, Mid-day Meal Scheme, Rajiv Gandhi Drinking Water Mission, Total Sanitation Campaign, National Rural Health Mission, Integrated Child Development Services, National Rural Employment Guarantee Scheme and Jawaharlal Nehru National Urban Renewal Mission," the Minister added.
The budgetary provision for the development of North Eastern Region has been increased from Rs.1176.00 crores to Rs. 1350.00 crores and the Tribal Affairs Ministry gets Rs.1656.90 crores from Rs.1498.82 crores, Kyndiah said. The NEC budget has been increased from Rs. 461.50 crores to about Rs. 600.00 crores, which amount to 30% increase, he said.
"The NEC budget was stagnated for the last five years and this increase shows the deep commitment of the UPA Government for the North Eastern Region," he added.
From the mandatory 10 percent allocation for the flagship programmes alone, this would amount to an additional allocation of Rs.4,870 crore in 2006-07, Kyndiah said. The total budget allocation for the NER is Rs.12,041 crore which includes Rs.1,350 crore provided to the Ministry of Development of North Eastern Region (DONER). From BE 2005-06 to BE 2006-07, the step up is 18 per cent, he said.
On a like to like basis, the allocations for schemes benefiting only SCs and STs have been enhanced by 14.5 per cent to Rs.2,902 crore and the allocations for schemes with at least 20 per cent allocation for SCs and STs have been enhanced by 13.9 per cent to Rs.9,690 crore, Kyndiah pointed out. A special accelerated road development programme for the North Eastern Region at an estimated cost of Rs.4,618 crore has been approved.
The region will also benefit from enhanced allocation for Horticulture and renewed thrust on food processing industry, the Minister added. Oppostion parties have however, dismissed the Union Buget for not taking up big projects in the NE region.
Nothing to cheer about: NE experts
Guwahati: Contrary to Kyndiah's views on the union budget presented in the Parliament on Wednesday, the Kamrup Chamber of Commerce (KCC) in the city have criticised the Budget as they feel that there is nothing for the northeast in the budget.
Talking to newsmen, KCC president Mahabir Prasad Jain said that Rs 12000 crore budgetary allocation for the northeast is too less for the seven states and pointed out that it should have been at least 25000 crore like the West Bangal. "While the fund allocation for West Bengal is 25,000 crore, the allocation of Rs 12,000 crore for the northeast is not enough," he said and added that development is not possible in the region unless this issues are given proper attention.
Besides, the union budget has totally neglected certain issues like tourism, education, agriculture, Jain pointed out while adding even the allocation for tea industry-Rs 100 crore is not sufficient. "There are about 850 tea garden in Assam alone and each one of them requires at least Rs 100 crore for their revival," Jain pointed out while saying that the budget should have allocated some more funds for revival of tea tourism sector.
"The budget had also neglected the issues like unemployment problem of the region and there is no scheme for these," he said and added that about one lakh of student are graduating from Assam alone each year. The finance minister should have taken these issues for consideration before preparing the budget, Jain added.
He further urged the 24 MPs from the region and the seven chief ministers to take up these issues before the Prime Minister and the Finance Minister so that some corrective measures could be taken. (NNN)
Infiltration has come down, claims Gogoi
From Our Correspondent
Guwahati: Assam Chief minister, Tarun Gogoi on Wednesday claimed that infiltration from Bangladesh across the border had come down to negligible level while contesting the opposition BJP’s demand that infiltration was on the upswing.
Mr Gogoi challenged the BJP General secretary and poll in charge for Assam, Pramod Mahajan to prove his allegation that there is continuing large-scale infiltration of Bangladeshi immigrants to Assam. I challenge Mr Mahajan to prove. If he can prove this charge I will quit otherwise he should quite politics."
Mr Gogoi, however admitted that there had been attempts to infiltrate into Assam that, he said, had been successfully thwarted by the security forces at the border.
Naga varsity students to continue stir over VC’s resignation
Kohima: Even though Prof G.D. Sharma tendered his resignation from the post of Vice Chancellor of Nagaland University on Tuesday, the Post Graduate Students’ Union (PGSU) today threatened that it would continue its agitation till the resignation letter was accepted by the office of the Visitor in New Delhi.
The PGSU took a decision to this effect during a general body meeting comprising all the three campuses today. The three campuses of the PGSU decided to continue with academic closure in all the campuses unless New Delhi accepted Prof Sharma’s resignation letter. This is the third time Prof Sharma had stepped down as the VC. Earlier, in 2001 and 2002, he had resigned from the post but the Union Ministry of Human Resources Development (MHRD) had reportedly refused to accept his resignation letter and he continued.
Although the PGSU would continue with academic closure in all the three campuses it knowing the problems of some of the students decided to exempt academic closure for the B.Sc Agri – SASRD final year and for their RAWE programme and the students involved in final examination from this decision.
The PGSU appealed to the lecturers concerned to perform their duty. "In case of failure on the part of the lecturers the PGSU should not be held responsible for hampering and jeopardizing the career of students but the lecturers failing to perform their duty will be held responsible," the PGSU added.
Meanwhile, the CEC of NUTA at a meeting also resolved to continue the VC's resignation letter was accepted. by the Visitor and MHRD. However, the CEC exempted the RAWE programme underway at SASRD, Medziphema.
ANSAM alleges underground outfits’ hand in tribal rape cases
Imphal: While expressing its deep concerned over the alleged manhandling of M.Naobi Chanu by Manipur police commandos in their custody, All Naga Students Association,Manipur (ANSAM) has said that it had been beyond doubt that ten innocent Hmar girls at Lungthuilain village of Churachandpur district had been raped on January-16 by "valley based/non-tribal" underground organisations.
The Naga students' body stated that the act was a horrifying and shameful one "because it dishonour the dignity of women and humanity". It also called upon all the sensible organisations and individuals to join hands in thwarting against those evil forces who work against the hill people in particular and the humanity in general.
Meanwhile, ANSAM strongly condemned the alleged torture and dishonouring of women dignity by Manipur police commandos to M. Naobi Chanu.The Naga students stated that the "disdainful activities inflicted upon M.Naobi Chanu is unwarranted." It said that ANSAM's sincere appeal to the state machineries to respect the human rights of every citizen while exercising their duties.
Meghalaya to benefit from trade expansion with B’desh, Thailand
From a correspondent
Guwahati: Bangladesh and Thailand are all set to exchange trade benefits with Meghalaya very soon, which is expected to boost trade prospects for both the sides. Representatives from both the countries showed keen interest to expand network in Meghalaya.
Exchanging views with a four member delegation from Laitumkhiah Sports, Social and Cultural Club of Meghalaya in the premises of the ongoing 13th International Guwahati Trade Fair in the city, Sabiha Haque, Information Officer , Export Promotion Bureau, Bangladesh viewed that she is hopeful that trade ties with Meghalaya would fetch good results as the state is geographically close to Bangladesh.
The Meghalaya delegation comprised of Anthony Hek, John E. Nongbri, M Fancon and A. Pyngrope. Haque's opinion was also echoed by various other entrepreneurs from Bangladesh like ACME Group, the second largest pharmaceutical company of the country that is currently exporting products to 22 countries, besides companies dealing in dry cells and a host of furniture dealers.
Meanwhile, with an aim to boost trade prospects of Thai products in Meghalaya, entrepreneurs from Thailand are contemplating appointing distributors in the picturesque city for Thai products.Mrs. Surang Pornvis-utrakul, proprietor of an herbal products manufacturing company, while indulging in a conversation with Meghalaya delegates said, "This trade relation will surely earn revenues for both the sides".
Beside Surang, manufacturer of various items like artificial flower, handicrafts, jewelries and watches also backed the concept of opening up trade avenues between the two sides.
National | Shillong | Editorial | Regional |
![]()
Make This Your
HomePage! |
About Us | Contact Us | Photo Gallery
Copyright © 2002 The Shillong Times. All rights reserved.