Saturday, July 19, 2025
spot_img

Sedition and defamation

Date:

Share post:

spot_imgspot_img

The Supreme Court has told the authorities that criticism of government is not essentially an offence under the sedition law. Nor is it under the defamation law. The 1962 Kedar Nath Singh v/s State of Bihar case made it clear that sedition law operated only when there was violence or proven incitement to violence. The recent reminder is useful as sedition charges are being leveled in large numbers and carelessly. The cases which readily come to mind include student protest at the Jawaharlal Nehru University or a Kashmir debate organized by Amnesty or former Congress MP Ramia showering praise on the people of Pakistan. Governments run by different parties in this country are prone to misuse the law to suppress dissent and stifle slogans which are of no consequence. Minister of State for home Kiran Rijiju said in Parliament that the definition of sedition in the IPC is so wide that anybody who speaks against the government can be accused of it and imprisoned for life.

Criminal defamation charges are made in arbitrary ways to gag and muzzle offending views. Sedition and criminal defamation go back to the days of the British Raj. India’s first Prime Minister, Jawaharlal Nehru found the sedition law highly objectionable and obnoxious. He wanted it removed in 1951. However, Prime Minister Rajiv Gandhi tried to introduce an anti-defamation bill. But to him and his supporters defamation meant character-assassination without substantiation. But under tremendous pressure from the opposition and the Press, he had to withdraw the bill. There have been undoubtedly cases of irresponsible defamatory articles published in certain magazines which led to their closure. There should be a fine distinction between such irresponsible writings and healthy criticism of government.

spot_imgspot_img

Related articles

Sajid Nagi wins Meghalaya’s first international powerlifting medal

Shillong, July 18: In a landmark achievement for Meghalaya sports, Sajid Nagi has become the first athlete from...

Modi’s remarks on Bengali ‘asmita’ pack of lies: TMC

KOLKATA, July 18: Dubbing Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s statements during a rally in West Bengal’s Durgapur on Friday...

How visitors grapple with interval curse in England

Manchester, July 18: As India prepares for the fourth Test of the Anderson-Tendulkar Trophy at Old Trafford, a...

Root 120 away from becoming 2nd-highest Test run-getter

Manchester, July 18: England’s star batter Joe Root is on the cusp of rewriting Test cricket history as...