Wednesday, April 2, 2025

Food v/s Privacy

Date:

Share post:

In a Supreme Court hearing, a senior advocate, CA Sundaram asserted that basic needs should take precedence over the right to privacy. The Judges ruled that economic rights should not curtail fundamental rights. The emphasis on economic rights is an argument for Communist authoritarianism. Amartya Sen has contended that famines are less widespread in democratic countries as freedom of expression ensures that famine reports cannot be suppressed. It is true that projects like Jan Dhan, Aadhar and Mobile Governance require collection of citizens’ data for facilitating welfare measures. But the authorities doing it should avoid misuse. Digital India calls for firm data protection by the Government. That means the apex court should always defend the right to privacy. At the same time, legislation is necessary to protect data privacy.

The law should make it necessary that an individual’s consent is obtained before collecting and processing personal data. But there should be exceptions. There should be strict accountability in case of data breaches. Procedures and punishments should be laid down in detail. India is a signatory to international treaties guaranteeing the right to privacy. A BJP MP has tabled a Data (Privacy and Protection) bill, 2017 in Parliament to protect citizens’ data. In such cases, private legislation may be called for. In the final analysis, however, the choice between food and privacy seems unreal. What is food security worth with a sizeable BPL population in the country? And the right to privacy can mean refusal to disclose real income and salting away of black money. The opposite may mean disinformation and harassment.  

Previous article
Next article

Related articles

Sports Snippets

Charlotte Edwards appointed head coach of England’s women’s team London, April 1: Former England captain Charlotte Edwards was appointed...

Ed Sheeran shares video grooving with auto driver in India

Popular British singer Ed Sheeran gave a shout-out to an Indian auto rickshaw driver who took him around...

AR Rahman announces ‘Wonderment’ tour

Music maestro AR Rahman is all set to kick off his much-awaited ‘Wonderment’ worldwide tour in Mumbai. The tour...

Malaika shares post amid dating rumours with Sangakkara

Malaika Arora has shared an inspiring post about a ‘strong tomorrow’ on social media amid ongoing dating rumors...