Wednesday, July 9, 2025
spot_img

Speaker is sole authority, say experts

Date:

Share post:

spot_imgspot_img

NEW DELHI, Dec 1: Noted constitutional experts are unanimous that it is the Speaker of the Legislature who alone holds the key to the issue of application of anti-defection law to 12 others MLAs who left Congress and joined AITC recently.
Famous constitutional lawyer and former Secretary General of Lok Sabha PDT Achary when contacted on Wednesday commented that the speaker has to take a call, if he is satisfied, against the MLAs, under anti-defection law. If aggrieved by speaker’s ruling, the MLAs can approach the court law for redressal.
Another Supreme Court lawyer and expert in constitutional matters, Geeta Luthra, also opined that the tenth schedule of the Constitution is clear and categorical in respect of Anti Defection law. If the two-third number is proven then anti defection will not apply. In the case of Meghalaya two-third of the MLAs led by Mukul Sangma, resigned from the party to join the AITC and decision was formally conveyed to the Speaker Metbah Lyngdoh.
These legal practitioners pointed out that although para 4 of the 10th Schedule of the Constitution virtually prohibits defection all together following the last amendment, it allows merger of one political party with another with sanction of its legislative unit having two-third majority. At the same time, the same paragraph excludes from disqualification in the case of mergers of political parties provided that such a merger is backed by two-thirds of the members of the legislative party.
Some knowledgeable circles, however, point out that the AITC is not a political party in existence in Meghalaya. Further, Congress being a national party cannot go by the decision of its state unit even if it is supported by two-third of its MLAs, they said.
The Speaker had earlier ruled out any illegality in their joining the TMC. But he had also sought top legal opinion in case the matter goes to court.
This provision in Paragraph 6 mandates the Chairman or the Speaker of the respective legislative house to be the ultimate decision-making authority in case the decision for disqualification arises. It also allows the courts to intervene in matters of disqualification.

spot_imgspot_img

Related articles

LoP Gandhi to address key issues concerning farmers, tribals, women during Odisha visit

Bhubaneswar, July 9: Odisha Pradesh Congress Committee President, Bhakta Charan Das, on Wednesday announced that Congress MP and...

Ravi Shankar Prasad slams opposition over Bihar bandh, alleges pressure tactics on judiciary

New Delhi, July 9: Senior BJP MP and former Union Minister Ravi Shankar Prasad launched a scathing attack...

Punjab Police foil terror plot backed by Pakistan’s ISI

Chandigarh, July 9: Punjab Director General of Police (DGP) Gaurav Yadav said here on Wednesday that the state...

16th Agriculture leadership conclave: Argentina reaffirms commitment to agri-cooperation with India

New Delhi, July 9: At the two-day Agriculture Leadership Conclave 2025, Argentina underlined the importance of its deepening...