Of misleading and defamatory news headlines

Date:

Share post:

spot_imgspot_img

Editor,
I am writing as a concerned citizen regarding the news article published on December 12, 2025, in a local Khasi daily, with the headline: “Da ki lak shu bam ei U CEO ka Municipal, hynrei sha ophis pat um ju wan.” This translates literally to: “CEO of Shillong Municipality eats lakhs of rupees but never comes to the office.”
While the report mentions real concerns raised by the VPP Youth Wing, led by Marbud Dkhar, about not being able to meet Mr. P.K. Boro, the Chief Executive Officer (CEO), at his office, I find the wording of the headline deeply troubling even if it was meant in a figurative way.
At first glance, the phrase “eats lakhs of rupees” suggests that the CEO is taking public money for himself in a wrong or corrupt way. It sounds like he is misusing funds, not simply receiving a legal salary. Even if the words were meant to point to his pay, the expression is misleading and can be misunderstood. In everyday talk and news reporting, such language often points to theft or abuse of power, not fair wages.
This is also a concern under the new Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS), 2023, where Section 356 deals with defamation. It says that harming someone’s name by saying they are corrupt or dishonest is a crime, unless it is true and done for public good. While people can and should question public officials, such criticism must be based on facts and spoken responsibly. A headline using sharp, accusing words like “eats lakhs” may go too far especially when the report itself gives no proof of financial misuse.
Also, the CEO manages three or more Departments under the Meghalaya State Government. His job entails several responsibilities and may need him to travel, attend meetings, or visit sites outside the main office. Being away does not always mean he is avoiding work. Still, it is fair for citizens to expect better access and transparency.
The media has an important role in watching over those in power. But this duty also means being clear, fair, and accurate. Headlines form first impressions fast. When they use unclear or emotional phrases especially about money and duty they can create false anger and harm trust in both leaders and the press.
The editor must think carefully before using figures of speech in headlines that could mislead or accuse without proof. A better headline could have been: “Public Raises Concern Over SMB, CEO’s Absence from Office.” At the same time, one might thoughtfully ask: Is it effective for a single officer to lead multiple departments? How does this arrangement impact day-to-day governance and public access? These are questions worth reflecting on, not to assign blame, but to strengthen systems and service delivery.
Let us continue to uphold truth and fairness not only in what we report, but in how we frame our news captions.
Yours etc.,
Dr. Omarlin Kyndiah,
Via email

Messi’s Kolkata Meltdown: When GOAT Dreams Drown in VIP Chaos

Editor,
The recent fiasco surrounding Lionel Messi’s visit to Salt Lake Stadium in Kolkata on December 13, 2025, as part of his GOAT India Tour, stands as a stark indictment of our event management priorities and the unchecked VIP culture that plagues public spectacles in India. What was meant to be a joyous celebration of football’s global icon descended into chaos, with frustrated fans vandalizing the historic venue after being denied even a glimpse of the Argentine maestro. Messi, fresh off his MLS triumph, departed the stadium after a mere 22 minutes, leaving behind smashed fibreglass seats, torn canopies, and a deep sense of betrayal among thousands of paying supporters.
This was no mere logistical hiccup; it exposed a systemic rot where the elite—politicians and dignitaries—were ushered into prime enclosures while ordinary fans, many of whom had travelled miles and spent their hard-earned money, didn’t even see a strand of GOAT’s hair. Videos circulating online show the unchecked surge of the crowd, a direct result of poor crowd control and inadequate security planning by the organizers and local authorities. Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee’s apology is a step forward, but it rings hollow without accountability. Why was the All India Football Federation (AIFF) not informed about the event, especially at a venue as iconic as Salt Lake?
Messi’s brief appearance should have been a unifying moment, not a flashpoint for rioting born of dashed dreams. This is all the more poignant as our domestic game languishes in disarray: the Indian Super League, heralded as a revival force, now teeters on the brink with its 2025-26 edition indefinitely suspended amid acrimonious standoffs between the All India Football Federation, club owners, and broadcasters over media rights and revenue shares. Stadiums echo with sparse crowds, grassroots talent drains away untapped, and bureaucratic tangles throttle the sport’s momentum, leaving a nation of aspiring enthusiasts adrift in frustration. It’s time to rally for sweeping changes and prioritize the passion of the people over the privileges of the few. Only then can we host global stars without embarrassing ourselves on the world stage.
Let this debacle be a wake-up call for future events and Indian Football. The AIFF and state government owe the fans a thorough inquiry and concrete changes—not just apologies.
Yours etc.,
Anil Thapa,
Via email

Lets Rock Shillong!

Editor,
Being a hardcore rock fan, I would like to extend my sincere thanks to Hon’ble Chief Minister Conrad K. Sangma, Meghalaya Tourism, and the entire event management team “The Circus” for bringing the legendary band Def Leppard to Shillong. The announcement of an international act of this stature reflects strong vision, collaboration, and confidence in Meghalaya’s ability to host world class cultural experiences. I was genuinely shocked when I first saw the poster on a relative’s WhatsApp status and had to double check its authenticity, it felt almost unbelievable.
For decades, Shillong has been known for its deep rooted love for rock and live music. This upcoming concert already feels like a recognition of that legacy. It promises to inspire local musicians, boost local economy and further reaffirm Shillong’s identity as the rock capital of the Northeast.
Moments like these matter as they have the potential to elevate cultural exposure, boost tourism, and instill pride among residents. More importantly, they demonstrate what is possible when ambition is matched with thoughtful planning, execution and perfect follow through.
I hope this event also creates opportunities for collaboration with local tour operators, guides, hotels, homestays, restaurants, and local merchandise creators, allowing our local community to collectively benefit from this milestone while minimizing the trickling out of earnings.
Shillong has always had the heart of rock. Soon, the world will hear it loud.
“Let’s Get Rocked!”
Yours etc,
Shivani Pde,
Via email

spot_imgspot_img

Related articles

No hawker eviction in West Bengal till Durga Puja, assures CM Adhikari

Kolkata, July 4: West Bengal Chief Minister Suvendu Adhikari on Saturday gave an assurance that there will be...

Minister Scindia to lay foundation stone for Rs 2,500 crore Adani Group’s defence manufacturing plant in MP

New Delhi, July 4: Union Minister for Communications and Development of North-Eastern Region (DoNER), Jyotiraditya M. Scindia will...

PM Modi congratulates Trump, people of US on 250th Independence Day

New Delhi, July 4: Prime Minister Narendra Modi on Saturday congratulated US President Donald Trump and the people...

HM Amit Shah approves designation of 17 Pakistan-based individuals as ‘terrorists’

New Delhi, July 4: In keeping with Prime Minister Narendra Modi-led Central government's 'Zero Tolerance Policy' against terrorism,...