Thursday, April 3, 2025

For conviction in dowry death, establish cruelty first: Supreme Court

Date:

Share post:

New Delhi: The Supreme Court has said that for seeking the conviction of a person accused of causing dowry death, the prosecution has to produce evidence that establishes that the demand for dowry was coupled with acts of harassment and cruelty.

For the court to draw the presumption that the accused had caused the dowry death, the “prosecution has to prove, besides the demand of dowry, harassment or cruelty caused by the accused to the deceased soon before her death”, the apex court bench of Justice A.K. Patnaik and Justice S.J. Mukhopadhaya said in a recent judgment.

Speaking for the bench, Justice Patnaik said: “In any case, to hold an accused guilty of both the offences under Sections 304B (dowry death) and 498A (cruelty), IPC, the prosecution is required to prove beyond reasonable doubt that the deceased was subjected to cruelty or harassment by the accused.”

The court said this while setting aside the judgment of the Andhra Pradesh High Court and that of the trial court by which husband Vipin Jaiswal was convicted for committing cruelty on wife Meenakshi Jaiswal, who committed suicide April 4, 1999 on account of alleged physical and mental torture for her failure to bring Rs.50,000 from her parental home.

The trial court had also convicted Vipin’s parents, but they were let off by the high court.

The apex court said that since the prosecution has not been able to prove beyond reasonable doubt this ingredient of harassment or cruelty, “neither of the offences under Sections 498A and 304B, IPC has been made out by the prosecution”.

The court also referred to the suicide chit that Meenakshi had written of her “free will”, in which she blamed her own parents and family members for harassing her husband and said that she was taking the step as she was fed up with her life and the frequent quarrels.

Vipin had told the court that he had found the chit from the dressing table while cleaning the house. (PTI)

Related articles

Trump unveils tariffs

Washington, April 2: President Donald Trump announced plans for sweeping tariffs Wednesday, saying "our country has been looted,...

SC quashes HC order against The Shillong Times

NEW DELHI, April 2: The Supreme Court of India has quashed a contempt proceeding against The Shillong Times...

Kharlukhi raps Biren for remarks on PA Sangma

SHILLONG, April 2: Former NPP state president and Rajya Sabha MP WR Kharlukhi on Wednesday criticised former Manipur...

New snakehead species of fish found in Chokpot

SHILLONG, March 2: Meghalaya has once again gained recognition in the scientific community with the discovery of a...