Monday, June 9, 2025
spot_img
Home Blog Page 20095

More than meets the eye

2G Scam: Rift Wide Open

 By Poonam I Kaushish

 Political India is beginning to resemble a leaking sieve. Wherein our netagan seem to have got all their connections crossed and jangled. Be it Manmohan Singh’s UPA II Government, Congress or the Opposition BJP. A classic case of star spangled jinx!

 Anyone looking for proof would not have to look far as self-confessed goof-ups have become the symbol of directionless and comatose governance UPA style. The latest, being a 14-page note sent by the Finance Ministry to the Prime Minister’s Office (PMO) on the notorious 2G spectrum scam.

Predictably, all hell broke loose as the 25 March memo seen by Finance Minister Pranab Mukherjee underscored his predecessor Chidambaram had not exercised his powers and “stuck to his stand.” to force then Telecom Minister Raja to take the auction route of the valuable spectrum.

After 8 long days of stony silence, the two protagonists Mukherjee and Chidambaram finally came together last Thursday in a purported show of unity to clear the air. Sic. Said Finance Minister Mukherjee in a terse 12 line statement, “Apart from the factual background the paper contains, certain inferences and interpretations that do not reflect my views.” Cooed Chidambaram, “I accept the statement as far as all us in the Government are concerned, the matter is closed.”

 Alas, Mukherjee’s statement not only failed to cut any ice but also left many questions unanswered. If the Finance Minister or his officials did not ‘indict’ Chidambaram in that note, then who did it, and why? The argument could be extended to the Prime Minister easily, particularly as the memo was a “harmonised note produced by various representatives of Ministries as an inter-ministerial background paper.”

 Questionably, can Mukherjee just see a note and assert these not his view? As Minister if he did not agree with the memo’s contents, vetted by officials including of the PMO that Chidambaram could have stalled Raja, nothing stopped him from appending his own views in writing.

Certainly not. Mukherjee and Chidambaram’s body language said it all. Both looked tense and upset notwithstanding the seemingly brave mask in place. There is no more than meets the eye. It is no secret that a wide rift exists between the two specially after the “chewing-gum bugging” of Mukherjee’s office early this year.

 Undeniably Sonia-Manmohan ordered a truce to save the Government from further embarrassment. True on the surface, the ‘ceasefire’ seems a loss of face for Mukherjee, but it may prove a deceptive victory for Chidambaram at a later stage. The Finance Minister has merely said the note does not “reflect his views.”

 If truth be told Mukherjee has cleverly further tied Chidambaram in knots. By not denying the statement’s contents he had made it official-Government speak. This has now only deepened the crisis and exposed the Government too Opposition onslaught which is raucously demanding Chidambaram’s resignation.

 This apart, it is all very well for Chidambaram to assert that for the Government “the matter is closed”. Certainly not. As the one in the dock, who has given him the authority to accept Mukherjee’s statement? Also, with Mukherjee giving legitimacy to the note in which the Cabinet Secretariat has contributed substantially by adding some 35 paragraphs, Chidambaram’s worries have only increased.

 Clearly it is not a question of bruised egos of warring ministers, but about loss of revenue. The 2G issue has serious legal implications with lower court ready to frame charges and the Supreme Court give it’s verdict on whether the scam should be still monitored by the Special Investigation Team. Chidambaram will be pushed into the defensive when the Apex Court resumes hearings after the Dusshera vacation.

Sadly, this lack of trust within the UPA leadership cannot be dismissed as merely a conflict of sense of self or ambitions. It is a direct fallout of this culture of lack of political accountability. This lack of conviction is symptomatic of a deeper malaise within the Congress arising primarily from the dichotomy between power and responsibility. Which cannot be excused as political delinquency and coalition compulsion.

The blundering by the Congress over the Telangana issue best epitomises this malaise. Consider: Andhra Pradesh which sends the highest number of MPs for the Party is split down the middle over this burning issue and is in the throes of strike which has entered its 19th day. Yet the Congress at the Centre and its State Government continues to vacillate on how best to end the impasse. Happy just buying time. But for how long? Speaking volumes about a leadership that has jeopardised the Party’s position in the one State, other than UP, that matters the most to the Congress and UPA?

 Look at the irony. Even as the UPA seems paralysed, the main Opposition Party BJP has been unable to seize the moment .It is boxed in by grandiose pretensions of being a ‘Party with a difference’ but is in fact a party with differences with votaries of the Sangh Parivar pulling in different directions.

 Today, it is grappling with dissensions as never before. So caught up are its Gen Next leaders busy taking potshots at each other, jostling to emerge numero uno has set many tongues wagging.. The latest fissure is that of Gujarat Chief Minister Narender Modi-Advani-Gadkhari. The cleft came to the fore when Modi absented himself from the Party’s two-day National Executive meeting last weekend. Reportedly, Modi is unhappy with Advani’s yatra for good governance and clean politics starting on October 11.

Aggravating matters, instead of starting his journey from Gujarat, Advani chose Jayprakash Narayan’s birthplace in Bihar and got Chief Minister Nitish Kumar, who is not a fan of Modi, to flag it off. The Gujarat Chief Minister is also upset that Advani did not attend t at his Maha-rally on the outskirts of Ahmadabad. The BJP President Gadkari’s decision to re-induct controversial RSS pracharak Sanjay Joshi, Modi’s diehard detractor, has upset him. Remember, Modi had made plain his prime ministerial ambitions during his recent Sadbhavana fast,

 This confusion is compounded by the fact that instead of marshaling all its resources, reconciling internal differences and exposing the ‘contradictions’ within the Congress and the Manmohan Singh Government, the BJP continues to hog the limelight for all the wrong reasons, when it should have positioned itself to corner the ruling combine at the Centre.

Happily for the UPA is riding the crest of the TINA (there is no alternative) factor. Even if the aam aadmi is burdened with crippling prices and corruption he has no alternate other than this Government. Already civil society led by Anna Hazare has usurped the Opposition BJP mantle. The so-called Third Front is non-existent. Consequently, UPA may have lost the moral fabric that once held it together but it will not sink.

Clearly, the time has come for the Government to smell the coffee. The Prime Minister needs to urgently pick up the gauntlet. Ideas are aplenty; the imperative need is to act firmly. Manmohan Singh must realize that the going has got tough. No longer will “work in progress” suffice.

Time to recall, late US President John Kennedy words: “When at some future date the High Court of history sits in judgment on each one of us… our success or failure in whatever office we hold will be measured by our answers to four questions: Were we truly men of courage? Were we truly men of integrity? Were we truly men of judgment? Were we truly men of dedication? —- INFA

Currents and Undercurrents

By BK Chum

 India has to monitor border situation closely

 Will the steep low in Pakistan-US relations impact India’s –particularly of Jammu and Kashmir’s security environment? Will it also have its fallout on India-Pakistan peace process? The questions call for perceiving the possible scenarios that may emerge on the two fronts.

One of the immediate consequences of the strained US-Pakistan relations will be that the Kashmir issue will be further pushed to the backstage of Pakistan politics. The infiltrations and terror violence in the state have already registered a sharp decline over the past couple of years and the issue no longer occupies the centre stage in Pakistan.

Not long ago, Pakistani rulers used to exploit the Kashmir issue to divert their people’s anger whenever the country faced serious internal problems. The establishment would raise the level of infiltrations into India particularly in Jammu and Kashmir despite the international opposition to its exporting terrorism to foreign lands.

 But the situation showed signs of a change in the Pakistani rulers attitude in the outgoing decade when India and Pakistan were twice close to solving the Kashmir problem. First it was during the 1999 Vajpayee’s Lahore bus journey climaxed by his closed-door agreement with Nawaz Sharif. Then it was when Manmohan Singh and Pervez Musharraf almost reached an agreement and its modalities.

 But both the efforts were torpedoed first by the Musharraf’s 1999 Kargil misadventure and then by escalation of the ISI-sponsored terror violence in Jammu and Kashmir and in other parts of India.

With the home grown terrorists intensifying their violence in the past couple of years, the attention of Pakistani rulers was diverted to countering the indigenous terrorists depriving them, at least partially, of their Kashmir weapon they had been employing for diverting Pakistanis attention from the country’s serious internal problems. The result was that except occasional reiteration of its combatant stand on Kashmir, the issue lost much of its focus in the peoples’ eyes, even if temporarily. .

 The latest downswing in the US-Pakistan relations has polarized the Pakistan’s public opinion against Americans further pushing the Kashmir issue to the background. The US’s senior most army hawk Admiral Mullen and others last month warned Pakistan that if the Pakistan’s ISI does not act against the Haqqani network based in North Waziristan’s tribal belt bordering Afghanistan, the US will take unilateral army action against the terrorist outfit. Mullen charged the ISI using the Haqqani network for its proxy war against American and NATO forces in Afghanistan. Pakistan’s all-powerful Army Chief General Kayani held an unscheduled meeting of the Corps Commanders to consider the developing serious situation. The meeting gave out that the Pakistan Army would not act against the Haqqani group.

 In view of the US and Pakistan’s political and strategic compulsions the above scenario may, however, undergo a change. It will be difficult for the economically ruined Pakistan to survive without American funds and arms aid. It cannot afford to annoy the US by converting its all-weather friendship with China into an anti-American strategic front.

On the other hand, two main factors will force US not to go too far in annoying Pakistan. The most important is the danger of its arms supply routes to the NATO and American forces in Afghanistan getting blocked by an annoyed Pakistan. The second factor is America would not like to create a situation which pushes Pakistan into China lap to the disadvantage of America’s strategic interests in the region which is going to be a theatre of major rivalry between the US and China because of its rich mineral and other natural resources.

 It is not without reason that both the US and Pakistan have started showing signs of softening their confrontationist postures. Even as General Kayani, after the Core Commanders meeting, announced that the Pakistan army would not act against the Haqqani group, Pakistan’s ruling and the opposition parties at their last week’s meeting while criticizing the US for its attacks on Paksitan, called for a dialogue with “our own people” in the country’s restive tribal north-west (the Haqqani network-based Waziristan).

 On the other hand, in reversal of his army’s hardliners attitude, President Obama has given Islamabad the benefit of doubt from charges of directly sponsoring terrorism, telling a radio interview that “the intelligence is not as clear as we might like in terms of what exactly that relationship (between ISI and the Haqqani group) is. But my attitude is whether there is active engagement with Haqqani on the part of the Pakistanis, or rather just passively allowing them to operate —-they have got to take care of this problem.”

The above perceived scenario may prompt Pakistan to exercise a greater restraint, even if temporary, on India-specific jihadi groups, like the LeT, from undertaking major cross-border operations. There may also be further lowering of the level of peddling in Kashmir. To expand bilateral India-Pakistan trade, Pakistan has since agreed to grant to India the status of Most Favoured Nation (MFN) to India.

 However, in view of Pakistan’s past record on reconciliatory moves, Pakistan’s offering of an olive branch may only be tactical but it can help to create an atmosphere conducive for normalizing India-Pakistan relations and also for the peace process in Jammu and Kashmir. The perception may appear too optimistic but optimism is the elixir of life.

In the backdrop of the above perceived scenario, New Delhi will, however, have to adopt an approach which helps normalize India-Pakistan’s strained relations. But keeping in view Pakistan’s record of duplicity, New Delhi cannot afford to down its guard in its dealings with Pakistan. (IPA Service)

Sports dept not yet ready with DPR for mega stadium

0

By Our Reporter

 SHILLONG: The Detailed Project Report (DPR) for construction of a new football stadium at Mawdiangdiang is being delayed owing to the magnitude of the project, it was informed on Sunday.

Commissioner and Secretary, Sports and Youth Affairs DP Wahlang, while speaking to The Shillong Times, said the department is still working on the DPR and it would take some more months before the report is ready.

Chief Minister Dr Mukul Sangma, had, last year asserted that the DPR would be completed by March this year. It is learnt that the State Government has already acquired 80 acres of land belonging to the Meghalaya Urban Development Authority, which would be handed over to the Sports department for the construction of the mega stadium.

An amount of Rs 70 crore has been fixed for the first phase of the construction and the amount would be escalated further for the second phase of the project.

Meanwhile, Wahlang has informed that the seating capacity of the stadium would be around forty thousand.

“The proposed stadium would be much bigger than JN Stadium and it would have all state-of-the-art facilities,” Wahlang added.

The State Government is also exploring the possibility of setting up a sports academy at the site, it was further informed.

The proposal for the new stadium, which would host national events like the National Games and other international sports meet, was conceived by the State Government last year.

Narine helps T&T stun Chennai

0

Chennai: The semifinal door was virtually shut on defending champions Chennai Super Kings as they lost the crunch Champions League Twenty20 Group A clash by 12 runs to Trinidad and Tobago thanks toSunil Narine’s magnificent spell , here on Sunday.

Chasing a small target of 124, all Chennai could manage was just 111 for six as batting was extremely tough on the M A Chidambaram wicket.

Off-break bowler Narine emerged as star performer for T&T as be bowled exceptionally well, claiming three wickets and giving away just eight runs in his four overs.

Coming into the crucial, Chennai did well in the first half by restricting the rivals to a paltry 123 for eight but the target could have been less had they not conceded 49 runs in the last five overs.

T&T managed those 49 runs largely on the back of a heroic innings from Kevon Cooper, who hit a 10-ball 28 with the help of three sixes and a four.

Opener William Perkins (34) top scored for the T and T while Adrian Barath (23) also played a useful knock.

Australian paceman Doug Bollinger (3/30) and spinner Shadab Jakati (2/18) bowled well for Chennai in the first half as they shared five wickets between them.

The target was not too big but batting was not easy and the small score proved quite difficult to achieve for the Chennai, who now have lost two of the three matches played.

Dwayne Bravo was top scorer for Chennai with his unbeaten 32 but that only reduced the defeat margin.

Now Chennai need to win their last match against New South Wales Blues on Tuesday and hope that a mathematical miracle help them make the cut for the semifinals.

T and T registered their first win and interestingly they too stand a chance to qualify for the semifinals as they take on Cape Cobras in their last group outing on Tuesday.

Anything can happen in Group A and a clear picture will emrege only on Tuesday as all the teams including NSW, Cape Cobras, T&T along with Chennai, who have the poorest run-rate, are in the semifinal hunt at least mathematically. (PTI)

Mumbai slump to first defeat

0

Chennai: Mumbai Indians paid the price of a listless batting display as they suffered their first defeat in the Champions League Twenty20 with a five-wicket loss to New South Wales here today.

Electing to bat, Mumbai could score a paltry 100 for seven in their last Group A league match with James Franklin top-scoring with a 51-ball 42 and only two other lower-order batsmen crossing double digit at the MA Chidambaram Stadium.

The bowlers, however, gave hopes of a memorable victory with a spirited fight by reducing NSW to 28 for five in the seventh over before they lost the plot and failed to break the sixth wicket partnership of Steven Smith (45 not out) and Ben Rohrer (26 not out).

The duo shared 73 runs from 10.4 overs for unbroken sixth wicket to guide NSW to their second win of the tournament by reaching 101 for five with three overs to spare.

Mumbai ended their league engagements on five points while NSW are on four with one match to play.

Defending a meagre total, Mumbai tried to make a match out of it as their fired up pacers ran through the NSW top order with Abu Nechim Ahmed (3/23) scalping three while Lasith Malinga (1/23) removed captain Simon Katich.

Ahmed removed Watson (3) with his first delivery with the ball first thudding on the pads of the batsman en route to hitting the stumps. Ahmed removed Watson (3) with his first delivery with the ball first thudding on the pads of the batsman en route to hitting the stumps. (PTI)

Cooper cameo hurt us badly, admits Dhoni

0

Chennai: Chennai Super Kings skipper Mahendra Singh Dhoni believes that crucial 28-run knock by Trinidad and Tobago’s Kevon Cooper hurt them badly as they face exit from the Champions League Twenty20 after losing today’s match.

T&T had scored 74 runs from 15 overs while batting first but managed to put 123 for eight on the board as Cooper batted extremely well towards the end.

Chennai lost the match by 12 runs after scoring 111 for six from their 20 overs.

Dhoni said he expected T&T to score 110 but Cooper’s knock made the target tough for them.

“I was looking to chase 110 odd runs. I knew even if they get a few good overs, I expected 110 runs but those extra 10 runs (that Cooper got) really helped them,” Dhoni said after the match.

Dhoni said getting the strokes was difficult as wicket was not tough.

“It became really difficult to rotate strike. They bowled in good areas. The ball was getting muddy and it was difficult to pick with their action,” he said.

The CSK skipper though was still hopeful for qualifying for the semifinals.

“We need to beat the next time, we’re playing the last game so if everything goes our way we’ll know what we need to do,” he said.

T&T skipper Daren Ganga was pleased to post a win as they had lost earlier two matches from winning positions.

“Always good to get a win. People back home will be pleased,” he said.

As his team also stand a chance to make the semifinals, Ganga was determined to win their last match on Tuesday. (PTI)

‘Had point to prove on Indian wickets’

0

London: England pace spearhead James Anderson is disappointed to miss out on the upcoming tour of India as he wanted to prove his worth in the sub-continent wickets after his below-par performance in the World Cup earlier this year.

Anderson, who was in red-hot form in the just-concluded series between the two sides recently, was rested by the selectors for England’s tour of India for a five-match ODI series and a one-off Twenty20 match.

“Of course I was disappointed not to go to India,” Anderson was quoted as saying by ‘Daily Mail’.

“I didn’t have a great World Cup there and I wanted to go back and show I could bowl in those conditions. They said they were thinking of giving me a rest. I said I didn’t want one. And they made their decision.

“I remembered first how bad I felt physically at the end of the World Cup and how I was bowling and also what we have on our schedule for next year – Test series against Pakistan, Sri Lanka, West Indies, South Africa and India and it all made sense,” he added.

Anderson knows that the selectors must have taken the decision keeping in mind the interest of the team but said he just wants to be in the thick of things and make up for the time which he lost because of injury.

“I have no quarrel with the selectors whatsoever because they make their decisions in the best interests of the team. But that doesn’t mean I won’t miss being involved,” he said.

“No one should need extra motivation for playing for England but from a personal perspective I’ve been through some tough times.

“Missing a whole year through injury was pretty average and there were doubts about whether I would ever be able to come back and bowl fast. Things did look bleak for a while and it took my wife Daniella to tell me to pull my head out of my backside,” Anderson said.

“I’m really enjoying playing at the minute, enjoying the team’s success and my personal success but you do recall times when you are injured or not selected and that does spur you on,” he added.

The 29-year-old right-arm pacer says he wants to be fit and keep improving to retain his position in the English team.

“I want to stay on top of my fitness to reduce the chances of injury and I want to keep improving as a bowler to keep guys knocking on the door at bay and to keep my spot on the team,” Anderson said.

“It is very hard to build up the kind of feeling we have in our dressing room and it is something you want to be part of and to protect, because it can be very easy to lose it,” he said.

“The emergence of new players keeps everyone up to their work. But that pressure is a positive thing.”

Anderson said though he missed out on the opportunity this year, he is looking forward to touring India next year for the Test series and show how good he can bowl.

“We want to create a legacy; we want to stay at No1 for as long as we can, to be the best England team for a long time, if not ever.

“Sure, I was not happy to miss out on this one-day trip to India. But I’ll still have the chance to go back there this time next year for the Test series and show them what I can do in their conditions,” he said.”And if winning there caps a year in which we beat all the others as well, maybe people will believe in our ambition as much as we do.” (PTI)

I saw Anderson tamper with ball, claims Gul

0

KARACHI: Pakistan speedster Umar Gul is set to kick up a storm as he has claimed that he saw English pacer James Anderson tamper with the ball last year during a Test match.

The seasoned pacer, who is tipped to make a comeback to the national side for the coming series against Sri Lanka, said ball-tampering was not new in international cricket and it was being done through legal and illegal methods by many bowlers and teams.

“I saw Anderson do it last year when we went to England. Then in the Ashes series Stuart Broad was seen roughing up the ball with his boots. All these methods are part and parcel of the game to obtain reverse swing with the old ball,” Gul said.

“Most of the bowlers tamper with the ball in international cricket,” he added.

Gul’s comments that are likely to ignite a new debate came when reporters asked him about the remarks made by Shoaib Akhtar in his controversial autobiography recently released in India.

The retired fast bowler, in his book, has admitted to ball-tampering and claims it is common in Pakistan’s domestic cricket. Shoaib has called on the ICC to legalise ball-tampering. Gul said if Shoaib was saying he tampered with the ball he must have done it.

“I can’t say much on that but yes many bowlers do it. When you use finger nails to scratch the ball it is illegal but when the fielders keep on throwing the ball on rough and dry pitches or the ball hits the advertising boards and sponsors signs, it is not illegal,” he said.

Gul said whether the ball was roughed up legally or illegally it remained an art to obtain reverse swing with it.

But Gul didn’t agree with Shoaib’s suggestion to legalise ball tampering insisting this would spoil the beauty of the game.

“It should not be legalised because laws can’t be changed on this and it should remain an art.”

Gul, who has taken 125 Test, 134 ODI and 47 wickets in T20 cricket, said Pakistani bowlers had always been accused of ball-tampering and it was nothing new.

“This talk about ball tampering is not new to us. But reverse swing is something that comes naturally to us and it is an art passed down from generation to generation,” he explained. (PTI)

Manoj wins stunner, Suranjoy out

0

New Delhi: Commonwealth Games gold-medallist Manoj Kumar’s sensational upset win over a European champion left him just one step away from Olympic qualification but it was curtains for Suranjoy Singh as he was ousted following a second-round loss in the World Boxing Championships in Baku, Azerbaijan on Sunday.

Manoj advanced to the pre-quarterfinals of the light welterweight division (64kg) with a thumping 19-7 win over European champion and fourth seed Raymond Moylette of Ireland.

Joining him in the next round from the Indian camp was Asian Games silver-medallist Dinesh Kumar in the light heavyweight (81kg) category.

The 12th-seeded Dinesh was declared winner at the fag end of his bout’s final round as his rival Bosko Draskovic of Montenegro was disqualified for bending too much.

Both the Indian boxers now just have to win their next bouts to qualify for the London Games next year from the first Olympic qualifying event.

Top 10 boxers (from 49kg to 81kg division) will make the cut for the Games.

While Manoj will next face China’s Qing Hu, Dinesh would be up against Australia’s CWG gold-medallist Damien Hooper.

“Manoj fought very intelligently. He targetted this guy’s body and invited him before coming up with his uppercuts and hooks. Dinesh was also very dominant throughout and even though Montenegro was not happy with the disqualification, the truth is that the guy was bending too much,” national coach Gurbax Singh Sandhu told PTI. But it was curtains for CWG gold-medallist Suranjoy in the fly weight (52kg) division as he lost 14-17 to Mongolian ninth seed Nyambayar Tugstsogt in the second round.

Suranjoy, who lost to Tugstsogt by just one point on countback in the opening round of the previous World Championships, was leading by a point in the second round before the Mongolian came back to notch up the win in the rollercoaster bout.

Suranjoy, an Asian Games bronze-medallist, opened the proceedings for India and finished a point behind at 4-5 in the first round.

He roared back in the second round to clinch nine points against his rival’s seven to make it 13-12. But Tugstsogt turned the tables in the final round to seal the issue.

“It is a very disappointing result. Even though Suranjoy fought back in the second round but in the final round, he got hit by a very nasty uppercut. That upset his rhythm and the Mongolian benefitted from that,” said Sandhu.

Dinesh was next up and he established a 14-6 lead by the end of the second round before his rival was disqualified. (PTI)

Honda’s Pedrosa wins Japanese MotoGP

0

MOTEGI: Honda’s Dani Pedrosa kept his cool during an incident-packed Japanese MotoGP on Sunday, easing to victory over reigning world champion Jorge Lorenzo by more than seven seconds.

Spain’s Pedrosa sealed his third win of the season at the Twin Ring Motegi circuit in 42min 47.481sec, while championship leader Casey Stoner, who started on pole, finished third despite ending up in the gravel during the fifth lap.

Pedrosa kept his calm throughout the action-packed race which saw five riders crashing out and three others handed ride-through penalties.

But despite his victory, Stoner, who finished more than 18 seconds behind Pedrosa, still leads Lorenzo (Yamaha) in the championship standings by a commanding 40 points with just three races remaining — in Australia, Malaysia and Valencia.

Stoner was in command early in the race before running off the track and into the gravel on lap five, which saw him drop to seventh.

He said his brakes had failed to respond after his bike began shaking but he managed to stay on his Honda and return to the track.

His Italian teammate Andrea Dovizioso led the race briefly before he had to perform a ride-through penalty for jumping the start.

Ducati’s Valentino Rossi crashed out on the first lap, dragging along Yamaha rider Ben Spies, who rejoined the race, and also almost taking down Lorenzo.

Pedrosa, who finished second in the previous three races, seized his opportunity and powered to the front, steadily increasing the gap with Lorenzo and earned a home victory for his team. (Agencies)